Annie Murphy Paul happens to be one of my heroes. I first learned of her research through a TED Talk and was immediately hooked. This excerpt from her Brilliant Blog was so compelling that I am sharing it with you in hopes to reach more readers, spread the word about her amazing work, and to encourage all to sign up for her Brilliant Report, a weekly newsletter full of the latest findings on how to learn smarter. I know I will be reading Amanda Ripley's new book!
Where the smart kids are
Note to Brilliant readers: What follows is my review of a new book by journalist Amanda Ripley, "The Smartest Kids In The World: And How They Got That Way." The review will appear on the cover of this Sunday's New York Times Book Review. I found Ripley's book to be powerful and persuasive reading and thought I'd share my take on it with you.—Annie
“If you want the American dream, go to Finland.” These blunt words from a British politician, quoted by Amanda Ripley
in “The Smartest Kids in the World,” may lead readers to imagine that her book belongs to a very particular and popular genre. We love to read about how other cultures do it better (stay slim, have sex, raise children). In this case, Ripley is offering to show how other nations educate students so much more effectively than we do, and her opening pages hold out a promising suggestion of masochistic satisfaction. “American educators described Finland as a silky paradise,” she writes, “a place where all the teachers were admired and all the children beloved.”
The appeal of these books, which include “French Women Don’t Get Fat,” “Bringing Up Bébé” and “Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother” (excerpted in The Wall Street Journal
under the headline “Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior”), comes from the opportunity to wallow enjoyable in envy and self-loathing — and then to close the cover, having changed nothing. We’re Americans, after all. We’re not really going to do it the Chinese way or the French way, superior as they may be.
But Ripley, a contributor to Time
magazine and The Atlantic
and an Emerson fellow at the New America Foundation (where I am also a fellow), has a more challenging, and more interesting, project in mind. Yes, she travels to Finland to observe the “Nordic robots” who achieve such remarkably high scores on international tests — and to South Korea and Poland, two other nations where students handily surpass Americans’ mediocre performance. In the best tradition of travel writing, however, she gets well beneath the glossy surfaces of these foreign cultures and manages to make our own culture look newly strange.
In reporting her book, Ripley made the canny choice to enlist “field agents” who could penetrate other countries’ schools far more fully than she: three American students, each studying abroad for a year. Kim, a restless 15-year-old from rural Oklahoma, heads off to Finland, a place she had only read about, “a snow-castle country with white nights and strong coffee.” Instead, what she finds is a trudge through the cold dark, to a dingy school with desks in rows and an old-fashioned chalkboard — not an iPad or interactive whiteboard in sight. What Kim’s school in the small town of Pietarsaari does have is bright, talented teachers who are well trained and love their jobs.
Read Full Post Here